How the judging and medals work

Entries

Producers are invited to submit their wines and provide us with the wine’s technical details, price and retail availability. Four bottles of each wine arrive at the Decanter warehouse and are logged, categorised and coded according to country and region.

Organising wines for DWWA judging week

Wines are organised for tasting by country, region, colour, grape, style, vintage and price. This ensures that wines are judged in flights against their peers. The price brackets are:

• Price band A – up to £14.99 (Value)
• Price band B – £15 to £49.99
• Price band C – £50 and above

The retail price brackets for Champagne Magnum are: 

• Price Band I: Up to £79.99
• Price Band II: £80 to £149.99
• Price Band III: £150 and above
   

Medals

The success of the Decanter World Wine Awards rests on its unique judging process and world-class judging panels. Wines are judged on a regional basis in carefully organised flights by country, region, colour, grape, style, vintage and price point. This ensures wines are judged in flights against their peers.

The judges taste wines individually. They know the region, style and price bracket, but they don’t know who produced the wine or the brand name. They then compare notes on the wine and reach a consensus on each wine’s medal.

Medal categories correspond to the 100-point scoring system used by Decanter and many top wine critics around the world.

Wines are judged on their own individual merits. This means it is entirely possible for several wines to be awarded a Bronze, Silver or Gold medal in one flight. Similarly, another flight may yield fewer medals.

The Judging Process

Stage 1: Bronze, Silver & Gold medals

In the first round of judging, Regional Chairs oversee their respective panels, settle any score discrepancies, and re-taste all Silver and Gold winners for consistency. Co-Chairs then re-taste all wines scoring 94 & above for final endorsement. Silver winners are therefore tasted at least twice, but up to three times, and Gold winners three times. This rigorous process ensures that each wine is reviewed thoroughly. Winning entries judged in the retail price band A category may be marketed as Value Wine, e.g. Value Gold. 

Stage 2: Platinum

Gold medal-winning wines are re-categorised by grape or style and re-tasted by a panel consisting of Regional Chairs and Co-Chairs. The wines are judged according to their origin and the judges will be aware of countries, regions, sub-regions, grapes, vintage and price bands.

There is no limit to the number of Gold winners which could be promoted to Platinum. Within each grape variety or style, more than one wine from a specific country or region can be promoted to Platinum. 

Stage 3: Best in Show

The Best in Show is the ultimate accolade at the Decanter World Wine Awards. In a separate tasting, the five Co-Chairs re-taste all the Platinum winners to select the ‘Best in Show’. When selecting the ultimate accolade, the Co-Chairs are aware of the origins, grapes, vintage and price bands.

The DWWA Judging Process